High Court Rulings


Writ Court cannot review order passed in revision; Matter appealable to SC

HC refuses to exercise extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of Constitution against its revision order passed u/s 11 of U.P. Sales Tax Act, 1948; Notes assessee’s grievance that dem...View More

Burnt coal residue from paper manufacture taxable as "Coal", not "residuary" article 

Burnt coal residue from paper manufacturing process classifiable as “coal including coke in all its form….”, taxable at 4% under U.P. VAT Act as it retains its combustible propertie...View More

Branch not distinct from HO, purchases for transfer outside State not taxable

HC overrules Tribunal, holds that purchase of goods viz. mentha oil by a branch and dispatch outside State to Head Office not taxable as ‘sale within State’; Rejects Revenue contention tha...View More

Cannot challenge concluded adjudication under settlement guise; Relegates importer to appeal remedy 

HC dismisses challenge to adjudication proceedings which directed confiscation of vehicle imported against concessional duty under false declaration / documents, thereby rejecting importer-assessee&rs...View More

No CVD on imported transformer oil, where indigenous manufacture excise duty exempt 

HC extends exemption from countervailing duty (CVD) u/s 3(1) of Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (CTA) on import of transformer oil, where excise duty exempt on domestic manufacture thereof under Notification...View More

‘Austenitic Variety’ Steel Bars distinct from ‘Bright Steel Bars’ for drawback purposes 

HC classifies ‘stainless steel bright bars of austenitic variety’ as “Articles made of Austenitic variety of stainless steel” under sub-serial no. 3803 of Schedule F to Customs...View More

Quashes service-tax demand on sale of airport entry tickets invoking extended limitation 

HC sets aside service tax demand on assessee in respect of airport entry tickets sold to visitors under license granted by Airports Authority of India (AAI), while holding that CESTAT had erred in con...View More

'Receivables' from Associated Enterprise towards Business Consultancy Services non-taxable before May 2008

Amount ‘receivable’ from Associated Enterprise (AE) for rendering Management or Business Consultant’s Services not leviable to service tax prior to May 10, 2008 in view of amendment ...View More

Joint Commissioner lacks jurisdiction to issue notice / revise assessment, quashes proceedings initiated thereto 

HC sets aside re-assessment proceedings initiated by Joint Commissioner (JC) u/s 64 of Tamil Nadu VAT Act, 2006 (TNVAT); Accepts assessee’s contention that u/s 64(4), Commissioner alone can orde...View More

Exercises writ jurisdiction; Quashes assessment including seller's discount in purchaser's taxable turnover 

HC sets aside assessment order to the extent discount obtained from sellers was included in cement dealer’s taxable turnover, finding same contrary to definition of “turnover” u/s 2(...View More