High Court Rulings


Upholds appeal rejection for pre-deposit non-compliance; Dismisses challenge to works contract assessment 

HC upholds rejection of assessee’s appeal for want of statutory pre-deposit of 12.5% of disputed tax, on the basis of decision in Ankamma Trading Company; Rejects assessee’s plea that said...View More

Dismisses "unfounded" challenge to Circular allowing adjudication of DRI's show cause notices 

Madhya Pradesh HC refuses to admit writ petition challenging Circular No. 276/104/2016-CX.8A dated January 3, 2017 by which the show cause notices issued by DRI, DGCEI and Customs (Preventive) were di...View More

Accords retrospectivity to substitution of tariff entry in ADD Notification; Directs refund 

HC accords retrospective effect to ‘substitution’ of entry ‘5402’ with ‘540247’ in Notification No. 51/2015-Cus (ADD) vide subsequent Notification No. 5/2016-Cus (A...View More

Denies concessional duty where imported inputs diverted to unregistered factory for manufacture 

HC denies concessional duty benefit to manufacturer under Customs (Import of Goods at Concessional Rate of Duty for Manufacture of Excisable Goods) Rules, 1996 upon diversion of imported goods for man...View More

"Rooh Afza" taxable at 12.5% applying 'common parlance'; Rejects assessee's 'fruit drink' classification 

HC upholds Revenue’s classification of "Rooh Afza" as an ‘unclassified item’ under Schedule V of U. P. VAT Act liable to tax @ 12.5%, in lieu of 4% VAT discharged by assessee as &lsq...View More

'Unjust enrichment' inapplicable to provisional duty refund pre-1999; Condemns Revenue's "pedantic" approach 

HC rules out applicability of unjust enrichment principle as provided u/s 11B of Central Excise Act to refund / adjustment of excess duty upon finalization of provisional assessment, in terms of Rule ...View More

Upholds demand on 'gutkha' basis production capacity & unaccounted packing material purchases, pre-May 2008

HC upholds computation of evaded excise duty in respect of ‘gutkha’ on the basis of assessee’s production capacity and unaccounted purchases of packing material; Rejects assessee&rsq...View More

Burden of proving ITC genuineness upon dealer; Upholds penalty for fake invoices 

HC upholds penalty u/s 70(2) of Karnataka VAT Act where assessee availed ITC on the basis of fake and false invoices of non-existent selling dealers; Rejects assessee’s claim that since Assessin...View More

Credit to dealer's account towards spares replacement under automobile manufacturer's warranty, taxable 

HC holds that credit received in dealer’s ‘Spare Part Account’ towards replacement of parts under automobile manufacturer’s warranty scheme, should be treated as actual ‘...View More

Allows provisional release of detained goods where 'origin' under investigation for exemption entitlement 

Bombay HC allows provisional release of detained imported goods upon execution of bond equal to 100% of assessable value and furnishing of bank guarantee of Rs. 1.40 Cr, which would be kept alive till...View More