High Court Rulings


Quashes order placing entity under Denied Entities List absent ‘sufficient reason’

Delhi HC quashes SCN, order placing assessee (a dealer of readymade garments and made ups) in the Denied Entities Lists (DEL) with a finding that order does not record reasons of such action; Cites vi...View More

Accrued substantive-right of tax-relief not deniable on technical-ground of Form-SVLDRS filing-error

Karnataka HC allows assessee’s writ seeking a direction to Designated Committee (DC) to issue revised Form SVLDRS-3 and Discharge Certificate in Form SVLDRS-4 considering pre-depo...View More

Failure to produce lab-report cannot be sole ground to conclude 'sales-suppression' against assessee

Madras HC holds that failure to produce the missing lab reports during assessment proceedings, cannot be the sole ground to conclude sales-suppression against assessee, quashes assessment proceedings ...View More

Sets-aside Revenue's 'mechanical and sketchy' order rejecting TED-refund to EOU on Govt.-supplies

Kerala HC sets-aside order rejecting TED refund claim of assessee (EOU), engaged in manufacture of parts and accessories used for ATM machines, supplied to NCR Corporation Private Limited, Puduch...View More

Restrains Revenue from recovering refund claimed pursuant to SC's decision in National Ship-owners 

Kerala HC disposes appeal challenging rejection of claim for refund of service-tax on foreign agency commission paid by assessee for services rendered prior to April 18, 2006 while answering the quest...View More

Revenue to accept application under Kerala Amnesty Scheme to settle only 'Sales-Tax' arrears

Kerala HC directs Revenue to accept Amnesty application of assessee to settle only the arrears under Kerala General Sales Tax Act (KGST Act) under the scheme; In rebuttal of Revenue’s view that ...View More

'Anti-virus Software' liable to service-tax as 'Information Technology Software Service', upholds demand

Madras HC holds assessee liable to service tax on supply of “Anti-Virus Software” in CD under definition of 'Information Technology Software Service’ (ITSS) u/s 65 (105) (zzzze) of t...View More

Benefit of proceeding-conclusion upon voluntary tax-payment restricted to 'Regular Assessment' cases

Madras HC holds that benefit u/s 28(2)(fore-closure of proceedings upon voluntary payment of duty/interest) is restricted to cases of ‘regular assessment simplicitor’ and not an assessment...View More

Declaration 'inadvertently' filed under wrong-category a 'rectifiable mistake', allows re-categorization under SVLDRS

Delhi HC directs Revenue to rectify the Sabka Vishwas (Legacy Dispute Resolution) Scheme, 2019 (SVLDRS) declaration and consider it as one filed under the “litigation” category instead of ...View More

Quashes notices/bank attachment initiated against ex-Director for recovery of Company-dues

Delhi HC holds that the Petitioner (an ex-Director), even if having knowledge of affairs of the company, is not vicariously or jointly liable for the dues of the company under the Finance Act, 1994, i...View More